I appreciate the intent behind American Tapestry more than the result. The programming is smart on paper — Barber’s lyricism, Marsalis’s rhythmic inflections, Korngold’s late-Romantic sweep, the Williams arrangement — but as a listening experience it feels curated rather than inevitable. Each piece is well played, even impeccably so, yet the emotional through-line never fully locks into place for me. The Calidore players are precise, polished, and controlled, sometimes almost too controlled. I miss a bit of danger, a bit of friction between styles. Instead of feeling like a living conversation across American traditions, the album plays more like a high-level recital stitched together with good taste. There’s craft everywhere, but limited urgency. Pros Technical excellence – Ensemble blend, intonation, and articulation are consistently refined. Thoughtful repertoire selection – The concept of mapping American voices through quartet literature is intellectually solid. Acce...