I admire this more than I love it. I can hear the quality almost immediately — the performance is focused, disciplined, and clearly knows exactly what it wants to do. The problem is that I end up appreciating its construction more than feeling carried away by it. Julian Prégardien gives the Evangelist real presence, and that keeps the recording alive for a long stretch. There’s emotional weight here, but it feels measured rather than urgent. I never get the sense that things are pushing toward a point of no return. The structure works in theory: it keeps moving, it keeps pointing forward. But after a while, the devotional flow starts to level out. Instead of accumulating tension, sections begin to feel equivalent in emotional weight. By the end, I’m left with respect rather than impact. I hear craft, conviction, and intelligence, but I don’t get enough escalation or emotional payoff to push it into the higher tier. A lot of it feels admirable without becoming necessary. Pros The nar...