Nikolai Lugansky - Schumann: Fantasie, Op. 17 - Carnival Scenes from Vienna - Humoreske (2026)

I respect this more than I feel it. Everything is well-shaped, coherent, and undeniably intelligent, but it stays too controlled to really become devastating.

The Fantasie works structurally because Lugansky clearly understands how to sustain the line across long stretches. Nothing collapses into disconnected episodes, and the quieter sections have real care behind them. But the performance almost never feels unstable enough. Schumann needs moments where the music seems emotionally larger than the pianist controlling it, and I rarely get that here.

A lot of the climaxes arrive correctly rather than necessarily. They resolve instead of tearing something open. The interpretation is elegant, but elegance isn’t really what I look for in this repertoire.

The recording also hurts the experience more than it should. The piano sound feels dense in the lower register and slightly boxed-in dynamically, which reduces the sense of space and emotional lift.

In the end, I hear a very serious and cultivated reading, but not one that leaves a lasting psychological mark.

Pros

The structural coherence still holds → the Fantasie keeps a convincing long-range shape from beginning to end
Lugansky’s control gives clarity to the writing → inner voices and transitions remain very readable
The lyrical passages have genuine warmth → the softer moments avoid empty romanticism

Cons

Too emotionally contained overall → the music rarely reaches the psychological extremity I want from Schumann
The climaxes don’t fully overwhelm → arrivals feel managed instead of transformative
The recording limits immersion → the piano sound feels heavy and uneven at times

Genre: Classical
Country: Russia

Final Verdict: 65% (Good Album)
Yearly Ranking: 153th / 392

Highlight: Fantasie in C Major, Op. 17: III. Langsam getragen. Durchweg leise zu halten


Made me think of:
Sviatoslav Richter
Vladimir Horowitz
Maurizio Pollini

#newalbum #newalbum2026 #albumrelease #newmusic #albumoftheday #nowspinning #NowPlaying #musicdiscovery
#Classical #NikolaiLugansky #Russia
#LP #Album #release

 

Previous

Next